Thanks to Domina Doll and Scarlet Lotus Sexgeek for putting this together

Best Sex Toy Reviewers is an annual list compiled by Domina Doll and Scarlet Lotus Sexgeek. Only reviewers who reviewed during the year of 2008 were considered, there will be a list for 2009 next year.

Each reviewer was rated separately by two people (Domina Doll and Scarlet Lotus did not rate themselves, their second rating came from a third party). The ratings were on a scale of one to five in four areas: Content, Organization, Originality, and Regularity. Each reviewer got a score out of 20 by each person and then the scores were put together to make a final score out of 40. Those final scores were ranked from high to low to get the list below

There were many ties. In cases where reviewers had nominations the number of nominations were the deciding factor for the ties. In cases where reviewers had the same number of nominations Domina Doll and Scarlet Lotus decided the order.

We recognize that this list is highly subjective. This is in no way a definitive list of reviewers, it is simply our list, and you can do with it as you will. We did use finite measurements, as discussed above, to create this list, but ultimately it is our own list. However, lists are fun to have and be able to point to.

1. Essin’ Em


2. Domina Doll


3. Beautiful Dreamer


4. Scarlet Lotus Sexgeek


5. Epiphora


6. Gabe and Elizabeth


7. Sinclair Sexsmith


8. Catalina Loves


9. Agent Ansley


10. Betty Rocket


11. Carnivalesq


12. J.D. Bauchery


13. Toygirl


14. Thursday’s Child


15. Dame Demi


16. Shay


17. Shasta Gibson


18. AlwaysArousedGirl


19. Freddy and Eddy


20. Dangerous Lilly


21. Jack


22. Erin Leone


23. Sleeping Dreamer


24. Ellie Lumpesse


25. Wendy Blackheart


26. Ducky Doolittle


27. Curvaceous Dee


28. The Porn Librarian


29. Lux Alptraum


30. Kyle


31. Naughty Secretary


32. Monkey


33. Nadia West


34. Alpine Subdreams


35. Bulma


36. Radical Vixen


37. The Beautiful Kind


38. Toys for Tarts


39. Sienna


40. Audacia Ray


41. Mariella


42. Ang


43. Lucy Vonne


44. Holden


45. Coy Pink


46. Backseat Boohoo


47. Bad Bad Girl


48. Jimbo Jones


49. Tess


50. BOX: Les Petites Morts


51. Zephyrine


52. N


53. Phaedra Fallen


54. Jiz Lee


55. Alisa


56. Syntax


57. Panthera Pardus


58. Red


59. Sommer Marsden


60. Mollena


61. The Countess


62. Adriana


63. Madeline Glass


64. Hussy Red


65. Trouble


66. Roxy


67. Sexorcism


68. Roxanne Rhoads


69. Amber


70. Roxi


71. Kinkerbelle


72. Sylvanus and Mina


73. Dark Lady


74. Sex Is Fun


75. Adrie Santos