I’ve been thinking about my childhood this week, and growing up gay in a northern English town. I’ve been looking for butch clues, working backwards to understand the recent moves forward. I’ve remembered plenty of clues, for example it’s only in the last few years I realised that not all dykes grow up wanting to be the prince who rescues the princess, some of them want to be the princess. When I was young my parents took us to the pantomime every year. A great British tradition where the prince (or hero) was always played by a female lead and the princess was also played by a female lead. Great role models for aspiring butches and femmes. I always wanted to be the prince; my beautiful wife however assures me she always wanted to be the princess.
I was also constantly mistaken for a boy, maybe not so much of a clue as a fact of life. I can’t, no matter how much I try, remember how I learnt to fasten a tie. I feel like I’ve always had that particular skill, I must have learned how to do it at a very young age. At school I was very disappointed that the girls weren’t allowed to wear the school tie, that felt like a big injustice. I had a dolls house that I can’t ever remember playing with except when I used it to jump off, I also don’t remember any dolls although I’m sure I had them. I do remember a set of cavalry figures and horses which I loved, seeing similar toys now still makes me smile. I loved being out on my bike but was incredibly envious of my brother who had a chopper bike. I also envied his racing track and electric cars.
The list of clues goes on and I recognised them as clues to my sexuality which of course they were to a certain extent. What I missed was the fact they also pointed to my butchness. In some ways it doesn’t surprise me that I missed that fact (or suppressed it), being butch back then wasn’t an obvious or valued path. Particularly in a town where the gay scene consisted of one fairly shitty pub opening its doors to the gay community on a Tuesday night. And where the few butch women had “the man” attached to their forenames (e.g. Pam the man) by their own community. There wasn’t a huge amount of understanding of butches and femmes around me at that time.
I did try a couple of times to step onto the right path, the butch path, but without any real understanding of what I was doing or where I was trying to go. Once I was working I bought several second hand mens suits which I wore to work for awhile. I’m not sure why I stopped. But I did for years just settle into being an average androgynous dyke, bordering on butch but not quite getting there. Well that’s different now, I am identifying as butch, thanks to my beautiful wife I now have several smart suits in my wardrobe and I am connecting more and more each day with my cock. It makes me sad to think that our wider community didn’t and doesn’t have a greater understanding of gender but I’m hopeful that will change.



